By Finn Zavros-Finnegan


PULSE, RESCENE’s 4th mini album, is a departure from the feeling of the group’s previous releases, asking us as an audience to pause and well, feel the pulse. 

First formed in 2024, RESCENE has continued to impress with their growing discography. Their name comes from the combination of scene and scent, with their official group bio describing this as a reference to the Proust effect, where specific scents can elicit very vivid memories. Unlike many of the standout groups of this generation, RESCENE is not managed or distributed by one of the bigger agencies and is instead under the management of The Muze Entertainment, an independent agency, making their success all the more impressive. This year alone, they’ve released four standalone singles, “Runaway” being my personal favorite. The five members, Woni, Liv, Minami, May, and Zena, have established a sound that feels fresh.

For the purposes of this article, my general definition for a “default” RESCENE track includes the following: fast tempo, tight production decisions, and a general feeling of “going somewhere.” Take a track like “Runaway”: it builds satisfyingly to the bridge, with the final chorus feeling like running down a hill. Even their most out there single, “Pretty Girl,” though it departs from default significantly, has these features. Big build, tight production, and a secret third thing which is their signature vocal performance quality. Usually, this is categorized by vocal fry or chest to chest-mix. Lyrically, their songs are generally 90% Korean with a few English words in the chorus. No matter how far they stray, RESCENE still remains tethered to that “default” sound. 

PULSE takes us far away from this default. 

The album opens with “Finest Thing,” written by Josh Lee and Derful Kim/Kim Hye-soo. The tempo is slower, though I realize it doesn’t sound slow if you aren’t familiar with RESCENE. This tempo will be key to setting the tone for the rest of the album. It’s in 4/4 time, the most common time signature in western music, with a straight ahead 8th note feel. The drums are simple with a kick that hits predictably, and the instrumentation is quite standard with few unique synth sounds or samples. It has no bridge, following a verse-chorus-postchorus form often found in simpler pop music. To add to this, the whole song is written in English. This isn’t new for RESCENE, they’ve released English versions of their more popular singles, but to my knowledge this is uncommon for their album tracks. 

Equally as uncommon is the vocal decisions being made in “Finest Thing,” and throughout the work as a whole. While all the members are capable of producing softer, breathy lines, RESCENE often gravitates toward vocal fry, with only one or two members singing in head voice. It would be untrue to say there is no vocal fry or chest voice happening— these lines are coming from Woni by the way, and they sound amazing— but most of this opening track is incredibly soft comparatively. 

Now, I realize I’ve set this album up as extremely different from RESCENE’s previous work, but that’s not wholly true. 

“With” is the culprit of my lies, and it’s almost like a sister-song to “Runaway.” It builds similarly, has a bridge, features vocal quality closer to default, and it’s primarily written in Korean. I almost wish this was the opening song. “Finest Thing” into “With” is a good transition, a trend that sadly doesn’t continue. What’s worse, I don’t even have much I can say about “With” because it’s one, a solid track, and two, it is in line with their previous releases. It’s just good, plain and simple. I’ve had it looping on my fall playlist since the 3rd of November, but it’s almost too good when you place it next to some of the other tracks on PULSE. 

This surprisingly familiar entry is followed by “백화요란 (Inside Out).” It has a similar feeling beat to the first two tracks, 4/4 and easy to groove to, while also diverting just enough from default to feel fresh. The bridge especially showcases some synth sounds that are ambient in nature. This isn’t unheard of for the group, but certainly a feature of the new producers present on the track. “Inside Out” was written by Josh Lee and Derful again, but they’re also joined by airy and ORiJiN of 153/Joombas Music Group. What really stood out on this track for me was the topline writing. Topline writing refers to the “topline” of a musical work, or more simply, the melody the singers sing, something I personally struggle with as a songwriter. I’d be very curious to know who specifically came up with the verse topline, as it feels downright infectious. The blend of Korean and English feels incredibly natural in this song, and I partly thought the entire thing was in Korean besides the line “inside out” just because of how wonderfully each line flows. 

A quick fun fact for you: EJAE of KPop Demon Hunters fame is listed as a composer for “Inside Out.”

RESCENE fans please don’t kill me for this next opinion. Also, for no reason in particular, this feels like a great time to reiterate that all opinions within this review are my own and do not reflect those of WUOG. Cool? Cool. 

I despise “MEME.” 

Let’s be clear, if this had been released as a stand alone single, I would have respected it. I still wouldn’t have enjoyed it, but I would have respected it. The production is good and the writing, besides the corny chorus and title, is good and, to the group’s credit, their performance quality is good. However, I despise what “MEME” represents. 

Lyrically, I see what they were going for. The whole album has a focus on being yourself, growing into who you are, and knowing your worth. In that sense, “MEME” fits right in! I was annoyed by how much I resonated with the message. Here’s an example: 

“The warmth that once felt unfamiliar

Starts to feel like spring the closer we get 

Little by little, we’re melting each other’s winter away 

You’re the only one who awakened the light inside me”

That’s gorgeous. I’m not being sarcastic either, that’s beautiful. In “MEME,” the use of “we” is actually referring to this person’s own self. It’s an incredibly fresh look at the concept of loving yourself, so the fact that both “Finest Thing” and this track managed to reinvent the wheel is certainly nothing to scoff at.

Then, why do I hate it?

The title. The hook. It’s so damn corny, and hey, I love some corn here and there. I am a huge ILLIT fan, and they can be corny queens (I’m looking at you, “pimple” and “Cherish(My Love)”). However, the difference between a song like “pimple” and “MEME” is that “pimple” leans into the extended metaphor fully. When an audience reads a title like that, they are expecting a song about that concept. The title is obviously meant to read as “meme,”, as in a popular internet phrase or inside joke, like the Wilhelm scream. While my icy cold heart refuses to find this concept amusing, if the song actually leaned into the double meaning, I would be so on board. Even one line about trends or the internet would be enough, but there’s just nothing. After at least 10 minutes of mostly default RESCENE, most of which was in 4/4, an R&B track with a corny title and a swung beat that doesn’t even attempt to lean into its namesake is just…

It feels pointless. 

Maybe it isn’t that deep to other people, but as a songwriter myself, it feels insulting. The first three tracks on this mini album have gone triple platinum in my headphones but I find myself entirely unable to save “MEME” to any playlist because of how awful it feels to go from “Inside Out” into that corny “Uh, uh” intro of this track. It’s infuriating because the song is so well written and produced! It lacks the PULSE of the rest of the album, making it feel like it was just slapped on to increase run time, instead of releasing as a stand alone. 

Instead of getting lost in the downright magical nature of the instrumental on “MEME,” I can only hold back laughter. I will never find myself going back to a song like this. Why would I? When this album itself has three other tracks that feel so much more coherent? 

That will bring us to the last track on PULSE, “Dragon.” Unlike “MEME,” this song grew on me, like a tumor. Acoustically, it fits a lot better next to the rest of the set. The songwriting is charming, following a knight protecting a dragon, a really fun subversion of expectations. The toplining is twinkly, and the instrumentation reflects that nicely. It doesn’t have a straight eighth note feel, but it still lands solidly on every quarter note, giving it a pulse that matches with the rest of PULSE. A solid outro that was unfortunately preceded by the worst RESCENE track to date. 

So where does that leave us? Is RESCENE cooked? Is it over? Should PULSE be thrown out entirely? 

Well, no. RESCENE is still relatively new. Considering they are fully independent as well, I can’t in good conscience suggest that anyone skip this album. It’s solid, and I’m sure if you asked someone else— perhaps someone with a warmer heart— they would have nothing but praise for it. But I can’t help but feel the presence of “MEME” on PULSE signals a larger issue with not just K-pop, but the pop music industry as a whole. It leaves a bad taste in my mouth. 

It feels like pop music has a rage baiting problem. To a certain extent, I can understand the motivation to maximize corniness. You will inevitably receive reviews like mine, or angry social media coverage making fun of the song. KATSEYE’s single “Gnarly” comes to mind, which was released with a controversial public perception. However, KATSEYE gained increased commercial success in the wake of the hate. Negative attention is still attention, and for an independent group like RESCENE, that could be vital.

We as artists, writers, executives, and producers should think carefully about when and where we are willing to divert from a project’s artistic vision in order to stir up controversy. Because that’s what I believe happened here, even though I have zero evidence other than my own experience being in writing rooms and studios. How do we satisfy fans while also driving engagement? How can we make it so that songs like “MEME” can exist while not feeling like an unnecessary add-on to a larger project? 

Overall, PULSE gives me hope for RESCENE’s future, as long as they stay away from tracks like “MEME.”

 

Listen Below:

Spotify

Apple Music

 

Leave a Reply